Cedar vs. Acrylic Cigar Humidor: Which One to Buy?

smoking a cigar by jay | Updated on January 26th, 2023

Are you a cigar aficionado looking for the perfect storage solution? Then you’ve come to the right place!

Cedar vs Acrylic Cigar Humidor

This blog post will compare cedar and acrylic humidors to help you decide which is best for your collection.

Read on to learn more about these two types of humidors and how they can help keep your cigars in optimal condition.

Compare Humidor Materials

When choosing the right material for cigar humidors, it’s important to understand the differences between cedar and acrylic.

Cedar is a classic choice, offering excellent durability and a natural ability to absorb moisture. On the other hand, Acrylic is known for its airtight seal and low maintenance requirements.

Both materials offer pros and cons when storing cigars, so it’s important to weigh both options carefully before deciding. In this section, we’ll discuss the materials in more detail and explain why they may or may not be right for you.

Compare Cedar and Acrylic Prices

When it comes to pricing, cedar and acrylic humidors are quite comparable. Cedar humidors may be more expensive due to the quality of wood and the craftsmanship that goes into them. Acrylic humidors can also be pricey, depending on the features and size.

However, both types of humidors offer excellent value for the price, as they are both built to last and will help protect your cigars from humidity and temperature fluctuations. The key is to find one that fits your needs and budget.

Pros and Cons of Both Acrylic and Cedar Cigar Humidors


  • Acrylic – Durable, Lightweight, Resistant to Temperature Changes, Easy to See Inside.
  • Cedar – Aromatic, Insulates Against Temperature Changes, Retains Moisture Well


  • Acrylic – Not Aromatic, Can Crack or Break Easily.
  • Cedar – Can Warp or Split if Exposed to Too Much Humidity.

Understand the Pros and Cons of Cedar Humidors

Cedar is a classic material used for its ability to retain moisture and maintain a consistent temperature when it comes to cigar humidors. It is also known for its rich aroma that can help enhance the flavor of cigars.

However, cedar is a higher-maintenance material and requires regular seasoning to keep it functioning properly. Additionally, the price of cedar humidors is usually higher than their acrylic counterparts. However, a cedar humidor can provide the perfect environment for aging cigars and preserving their flavor when properly maintained.


  • Cedar cigar humidors look more elegant and luxurious.
  • Cedar humidors can be very affordable.
  • Cedar can absorb moisture and regulate humidity better than acrylic humidors.
  • Cedar is a natural material, so it absorbs odors more effectively than acrylic.
  • The wood grain of cedar gives it a unique texture and character
  • They are easier to maintain and repair than acrylic cigar humidors.


  • Cedar cigar humidors require more attention when seasoning and maintaining the correct humidity level.
  • The cedar can impart its own flavor onto the cigars if not properly seasoned beforehand or maintained over time.
  • Cedar is more likely to crack or warp due to changes in temperature or humidity levels, whereas acrylic is not affected by these changes.
  • Acrylic cigar humidors are usually cheaper than cedar ones, making them a better option for those on a budget.

Understand the Pros and Cons of Acrylic Humidors

When you’re looking for a cigar humidor, you have many options to choose from. Acrylic humidors are one type of cigar humidor that has become increasingly popular in recent years.

They provide an airtight seal, which is beneficial for long-term storage and aging cigars, and they are low-maintenance and durable compared to traditional wood humidors. Acrylic humidors come in various sizes and designs, making them suitable for personal and commercial use.


  • Lightweight and durable
  • Low maintenance
  • Easy to clean and disinfect
  • Transparent, so you can easily see the cigars inside
  • Inexpensive compared to wooden humidors


  • Not aesthetically pleasing as wooden humidors
  • Poor insulation compared to cedar wood

Choose the Right Humidification Device for Your Humidor

Choosing the right humidification device for your cedar or acrylic humidor is essential. To maintain the ideal humidity level, you need to select the right type of device designed to fit the size and shape of your humidor. Humidifiers come in several varieties, including gel beads, crystal gel, and electric humidifiers.

Gel beads are great for smaller humidors, as they require minimal maintenance. Crystal gel is also great for smaller humidors and requires more maintenance than gel beads. Electric humidifiers are best for larger humidors, requiring very little maintenance and providing consistent humidity levels.

Once you’ve chosen your device, ensure you season your humidor properly to ensure that it is properly sealed and can accurately maintain the temperature and humidity levels you desire.

Maintain the Temperature and Humidity in Your Cigar Humidor

Both cedar and acrylic can provide a great environment for your cigars when it comes to maintaining the temperature and humidity within a humidor.

Cedar is more porous and therefore helps regulate humidity more efficiently. Acrylic is non-porous and much more airtight but requires humidification devices to maintain optimal humidity levels.

Both materials require regular maintenance to help ensure your cigars are kept in the best possible environment.

Consider the Size and Design of Your Cigar Humidor

When considering the size and design of your cigar humidor, it is important to understand the differences between cedar and acrylic materials.

Cedar is a classic humidor material, as it provides great insulation and helps retain humidity better than any other material. Additionally, it is aesthetically pleasing and can be crafted into various shapes and sizes.

On the other hand, acrylic humidors offer airtight seals, durability, and low maintenance. They are also available in various sizes and designs, making them a good choice for those who want to store their cigars without compromising style.

Maintain the Quality of Your Cigars in a Cedar or Acrylic Humidor

Both cedar and acrylic humidors can do the job when it comes to maintaining the quality of your cigars. Cedar has long been the preferred material for cigar humidors due to its ability to retain and maintain humidity.

However, acrylic is quickly becoming a popular alternative for cigar storage for its airtight seal and low maintenance. Acrylic is also more affordable than cedar, making it a great choice for those on a budget. No matter which material you choose, it’s important to understand how to properly season and maintain your cigar humidor to preserve your cigars’ quality.

Understand How to Season a Cigar Humidor Properly

When it comes to storing cigars, the right humidor material is essential. You may want to consider a cedar or acrylic humidor, depending on your needs. Cedar humidors are a classic choice, providing excellent seasoning and flavor retention.

On the other hand, Acrylic humidors provide an airtight seal and require less maintenance than their wooden counterparts. But no matter which type of humidor you choose, it is important to understand how to season it properly to ensure that your cigars stay fresh and flavorful.


You have two main options when storing cigars: a cedar or an acrylic humidor. Each has its unique benefits and drawbacks, so it’s important to understand the differences before deciding. Cedar humidors are typically more expensive, but they provide better insulation and are better for aging cigars.

Acrylic humidors are less expensive but do not provide as much insulation and do not offer the same level of protection as cedar humidors. Both materials offer great protection for your cigars, but understanding the specifics of each type of humidor will help you make the best decision for your needs.

smoking a cigar


Self proclaimed cigar expert. I've been smoking since 2010. I've practically lived at a cigar lounge from 10am to 10pm and trying every new cigar that came out for years.

VitalSleep Reviews

Snoring ruining your relationship?