7 Best Cigar Ashtrays Reviewed

by jay | Updated on July 20th, 2026

Most cigar ashtrays are designed for cigarettes and end up too shallow, too small, or missing the cigar rests that keep a 50-ring gauge robusto from rolling off the table. This guide covers seven options that actually work for cigars, across every use case: tabletop, patio, lounge, travel, and the car. All verified on Amazon with real cigar-specific specs.

One thing to know before you buy: a good cigar ashtray needs a deep enough bowl to hold the volume of ash a cigar produces (much more than a cigarette), wide enough rests to hold cigars that run 40-60 ring gauge, and enough weight to sit still outdoors. Keep those three criteria in mind and most bad buys become obvious before you click.

Find Your Ashtray in 30 Seconds

• Best budget tabletop 4-finger ashtray under $25 — Craftsman’s Bench Neptune. Black with silver edging, 4 cigar rests to 54 RG, 8.25 inch diameter, easy to clean.
• Best large outdoor patio ashtray — GUEVARA 8″ Round Porcelain. Deep basin, 4 rests, porcelain construction, heavy enough to stay put in wind.
• Best stainless steel 4-stirrup, the community standard — Stinky Original Polished Stainless. 8 inch diameter, 3 inch deep bowl, 4 stirrups, all-night ash capacity, windproof.
• Best for dark decor and modern spaces — Stinky Matte Black. Same Stinky bowl design in matte black finish, 4 stirrups, 8 inch diameter.
• Best deep-bowl outdoor ashtray — Craftsman’s Bench Boca Grande. 3.5 inch deep bowl, resin construction, handles 4 cigars, built for outdoor entertaining.
• Best floor-standing ashtray for a lounge or patio — Stinky Floor Standing Silver. 24 inch tall, 4 stirrups, 12 inch accessory tray, no table needed.
• Best car and travel ashtray — FESS Road Trip Car Ashtray. Fits cup holders, designed for cigars on the go, portable and sealed.

Quick Comparison Table

What to Know Before You Buy

cigar ashtrays are not cigarette ashtrays

Cigarette ashtrays are shallow, small, and have thin rests designed for something that runs at 8-10mm diameter. A cigar runs 40-60 ring gauge (16-24mm diameter) and produces far more ash per smoke. Using a cigarette ashtray for a cigar means your cigar rolls off, the bowl fills up every few minutes, and the cigar rests don’t hold the stick securely. If you are buying your first dedicated cigar ashtray, the minimum specs are: at least 7 inches in diameter, at least 1.5 inch deep bowl, and cigar rests wide enough to hold a 54 ring gauge cigar without it rocking.

how many rests do you actually need

One rest is fine for a solo smoker using the ashtray at their desk or in a chair. Two rests work for couples or regular two-cigar evenings. Four rests are the sweet spot for anyone who hosts: you and three guests each have a dedicated place to rest a cigar without it rolling into someone else’s ash. More than four rests on a single tabletop ashtray starts to get cramped unless it’s a very large bowl. Pick based on how you actually use it, not on the most rests for the lowest price.

deep bowl vs shallow bowl

Shallow ashtrays (under 1.5 inches deep) need to be emptied frequently during a session, and any wind makes ash go everywhere. Deep bowls (3 inches and up, like the Stinky design) are effectively windproof because the ash falls far enough below the rim that airflow can’t scatter it. If you smoke outdoors at all, prioritize depth over diameter. The Stinky’s 3-inch bowl is the reason it became the community standard, not its brand recognition.

stainless vs ceramic vs resin

Stainless steel handles heat best, cleans easiest, won’t chip if dropped, and holds up indefinitely outdoors. It’s the best all-around material. Ceramic looks better on a desk or bar, cleans easily, but chips or cracks if dropped on a hard surface and shouldn’t be left out in freezing temperatures. Resin is a middle ground: lighter than ceramic, more durable against drops, and the least expensive. It handles outdoor use well but doesn’t look as refined as stainless or quality ceramic.

cleaning your ashtray

Empty the ashtray after each session, not just when it’s full. Stale ash and cigar stubs left in a bowl for days create a persistent odor that no amount of rinsing eliminates. For stainless: rinse with hot water, wipe with a paper towel, done. For ceramic and resin: dish soap and warm water, rinse thoroughly, dry before next use. Never put a ceramic ashtray away wet. For deep-bowl stainless like the Stinky, a small bottle brush gets ash residue off the sides between the stirrups.

The 7 Best Cigar Ashtrays Reviewed

1. Craftsman’s Bench Neptune

[pr box=”B000SZU674″ template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$20-25 | Material: Resin | Diameter: 8.25 inches | Bowl depth: 1 inch | Rests: 4 (up to 54 RG) | Finish: Black with silver edging

The Neptune is the Craftsman’s Bench ashtray that most cigar smokers have seen in a lounge or humidor shop at some point. Solid black resin with a clean silver edge, four generous cigar rests, and a bowl that holds a comfortable amount of ash before you need to empty it. The 8.25-inch diameter feels substantial without taking over a table. Resin construction means it survives outdoor use and accidental drops without shattering.

The 1-inch bowl depth is the one limitation: it is not as wind-resistant as the Stinky’s 3-inch design, so it works best on covered patios or indoors where wind isn’t a factor. For open-air outdoor use in a breeze, the GUEVARA or Boca Grande are better fits. For desk, bar, patio table, or cigar lounge use, the Neptune hits the right balance of price, size, and looks at this price point.

Skip this if you smoke primarily outdoors in open-air conditions where wind is a factor. For indoor and covered-patio use, nothing at this price competes on looks and function.

2. GUEVARA 8″ Round Porcelain

[pr box=”B0B3J7XT84″ template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$25-35 | Material: Porcelain | Diameter: 8 inches | Rests: 4 | Bowl: Deep basin design | Weight: 1.98 lbs

The GUEVARA is the patio ashtray that Amazon cigar buyers keep coming back to: 8-inch diameter, 4 cigar rests, porcelain construction, and a deep enough basin that a resting lip keeps ash from scattering in moderate wind. At nearly 2 pounds, it sits firmly on a patio table without moving. The deep basin design is the key spec here: this is not a shallow ceramic dish, it’s built to hold actual volume and stay put outdoors.

Porcelain handles cigar heat well and wipes clean easily. The one real risk is the same as any ceramic: if it gets dropped on concrete or tile, it will chip or break. Don’t leave it on the edge of a table. For a covered patio setup where you want something that looks good, holds four cigars, and doesn’t need to move, the GUEVARA at this price point is hard to argue with.

Skip this if you need something truly indestructible or plan to move it around a lot. For a permanent or semi-permanent patio table setup, the GUEVARA is the right call.

3. Stinky Original Polished Stainless

[pr box=”B007P3FFKU” template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$40-50 | Material: Polished stainless steel | Diameter: 8 inches | Bowl depth: 3 inches | Rests: 4 stirrups | Finish: Polished silver

The Stinky Original is the ashtray the cigar community settled on as the benchmark. The 3-inch deep bowl is the key feature: it’s deep enough that ash falls well below the rim, making the ashtray genuinely windproof in most outdoor conditions. You can smoke multiple cigars through an evening session without stopping to empty it. The four stainless stirrups hold any ring gauge without the cigar rolling off. Polished stainless is heat-resistant, easy to wipe clean, and built to last indefinitely outdoors.

The stirrup design is also practical: each stirrup holds your cigar at an angle so the ash falls cleanly into the bowl rather than collecting on the rim. This means less surface debris and faster cleanup. Stinky makes this ashtray in multiple colors and finishes (polished silver, matte black, copper, bronze) so you can match it to your setup. This polished version is the original and most versatile.

Skip this if you smoke strictly indoors and want something more decorative. For any outdoor use or anyone who wants the best practical cigar ashtray on Amazon, this is the buy.

4. Stinky Matte Black

[pr box=”B08LR3XPSJ” template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$40-50 | Material: Stainless steel with matte black powder coat | Diameter: 8 inches | Bowl depth: 3 inches | Rests: 4 stirrups

Same Stinky bowl design and 3-inch depth as the polished original, but in a matte black powder-coated finish that doesn’t show fingerprints and fits modern or dark-themed setups better than polished stainless. If your patio furniture is black, your man cave has a dark color scheme, or you just want an ashtray that doesn’t look like a piece of kitchen equipment, this is the version to buy. The matte finish is more forgiving on smudges and looks better after repeated use than polished.

All the same practical advantages as the original: windproof deep bowl, all-night capacity, stainless stirrups, cleans in under a minute. The powder coat holds up well to outdoor use and heat. This is the ashtray for someone who already knows the Stinky is the right buy and just wants to match their setup.

Skip this if you want the classic stainless look or plan to use it in a traditional cigar lounge. For modern, dark, or minimal setups the matte black is the better choice.

5. Craftsman’s Bench Boca Grande

[pr box=”B009HBVFNO” template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$35-45 | Material: Resin | Bowl depth: 3.5 inches | Rests: Multiple | Style: Outdoor entertaining, tobacco leaf design

The Boca Grande from Craftsman’s Bench is the option when you want the practical benefit of a deep bowl (3.5 inches, actually deeper than the standard Stinky) in a more decorative, natural-looking package. The tobacco leaf design gives it a cigar-specific aesthetic that works well for a backyard patio, a man cave bar, or a barbecue setup where you want something that signals “this is a cigar space.” Multiple cigar rests accommodate a group session.

Resin construction means it handles outdoor heat and moisture well, won’t shatter like ceramic, and is easy to clean. Lighter than stainless, so on a very windy open patio it can shift slightly, but the 3.5-inch bowl depth means ash stays contained regardless. A solid middle ground between the value of the Neptune and the depth-bowl utility of the Stinky at a price that splits the difference.

Skip this if you want a sleek, minimal design. For outdoor entertaining where you want something that looks purposeful and holds a lot of ash, the Boca Grande is the pick.

6. Stinky Floor Standing Silver

[pr box=”B0087X63C6″ template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$80-100 | Material: Stainless steel | Height: 24 inches | Bowl: 8-inch diameter, 3-inch deep | Rests: 4 stirrups | Accessory tray: 12-inch wide

The Stinky Floor Standing takes the same windproof 8-inch, 3-inch-deep bowl from the original tabletop version and puts it on a 24-inch stainless post with a stable 10-inch base. No table required. The 12-inch accessory tray below the bowl holds a lighter, cutter, or extra cigars. This is the ashtray for a dedicated cigar lounge, a finished garage or workshop, a covered patio with a chair you spend time in, or any setup where you want an ashtray at arm height when seated without needing to clear table space.

Assembly is five stainless pieces and takes a few minutes with no tools. The carry handle makes it easy to move between rooms. If you have a cigar space you’re putting together properly, the floor-standing Stinky is the statement piece that anchors it. For smokers who want to understand more about building out a full setup, a quality cutter and lighter round out the essentials alongside a dedicated ashtray.

Skip this if you don’t have a dedicated smoking spot. For anyone setting up a cigar lounge, smoking room, or patio chair setup where you want everything in reach, this is the right investment.

7. FESS Road Trip Car Ashtray

[pr box=”B0BGJRSYWC” template=”horizontal”]

Price: ~$20-30 | Material: Stainless steel | Fits: Standard cup holders | Design: Sealed portable for car use | Use: Travel, vehicle, on-the-go

Smoking a cigar in the car without a dedicated car ashtray means ash on the upholstery and a robusto balanced in your hand at a red light. The FESS Road Trip solves this: it sits in your car’s cup holder, holds the cigar securely, contains the ash, and seals up when you’re done so your car doesn’t smell like a stale ashtray for the next week. Stainless steel construction handles the heat a cigar generates without warping or discoloring.

This is not a full-featured 4-rest tabletop ashtray, it’s a single-position travel tool. But for people who smoke cigars during commutes, road trips, or any time they’re out and need to ash cleanly, it fills a gap none of the tabletop options cover. Keep one in the car permanently and it earns its price in the first week.

Skip this if you don’t smoke in the car. For regular car smokers or anyone who needs a travel-safe ash solution, the FESS Road Trip is the right buy.

Buyer’s Guide

what size ashtray do you actually need

Solo daily smoker: a single-rest or 2-rest tabletop ashtray works fine. Regular solo smoker who occasionally hosts: a 4-rest 8-inch ashtray covers all scenarios without taking over the table. Regular host or herf smoker with multiple guests: consider a floor-standing option, or multiple tabletop ashtrays placed around the space. The mistake most people make is buying a tabletop ashtray that’s too small and then never being happy with it. When in doubt, go bigger on diameter.

indoor vs outdoor use

Indoor use: any material works. Ceramic and resin look better on a desk or bar. Stainless is easiest to maintain. Outdoor use (covered patio): any material works, but prioritize bowl depth over appearance. Deep bowl is the only meaningful wind protection. Outdoor use (open air): stainless is the only material that handles rain, temperature swings, and sun without warping or cracking. Never leave ceramic outdoors in freezing temperatures or full sun for extended periods. Resin handles outdoor use well but fades over years in direct sun.

what makes the stinky design special

Most tabletop cigar ashtrays have a bowl that is 1-1.5 inches deep with the cigar rests at the rim. The Stinky design inverts this: the stirrups hold the cigar above a deep 3-inch bowl, so ash falls well below the level of the rim. The result is that a moderate outdoor breeze does not scatter ash, you can smoke several cigars in a session without stopping to empty the tray, and cleanup is faster because all the ash is concentrated at the bottom rather than spread across a shallow dish. It’s a functional design improvement, not just branding, which is why it became the community standard.

ring gauge and rest width

Most cigar ashtrays specify a maximum ring gauge they accommodate on the rests. For a typical 50-54 ring robusto or toro, most 4-rest tabletop options in this guide work without issue. If you primarily smoke 60+ ring gauge cigars (gordo, double toro, big boss shapes), check the rest width spec before buying. The GUEVARA and Stinky both handle 60 RG comfortably. Narrower rests on budget ashtrays can let large ring gauge cigars rock side to side and fall.

ashtrays as gifts

A quality ashtray is one of the best gifts for a cigar smoker because almost everyone is using something substandard. The Stinky Original at $40-50 is the go-to cigar gift for anyone who smokes regularly outdoors. The Craftsman’s Bench Neptune is the right call for under $25 when you want something that looks intentional without a premium price. If you want to give a complete cigar starter package, a quality cutter and lighter are the other two pieces that pair with an ashtray.

Common Questions About Cigar Ashtrays

can i use a regular ashtray for cigars?

Technically yes, practically no. Standard cigarette ashtrays are too small and too shallow to hold a cigar without it rolling off, and the bowl fills with ash from a single cigar before you’re halfway through. A dedicated cigar ashtray costs $20-25 at the low end and makes a noticeable difference in the actual experience of smoking. It’s not a luxury purchase for serious smokers, it’s a baseline accessory.

how often should i clean my ashtray?

After every session is the right answer. Leaving cigar stubs and ash in a bowl overnight creates a smell that transfers to the surrounding room. A quick empty and rinse takes thirty seconds. If you let it go for several sessions, you need dish soap and a scrub brush. The Stinky-style deep bowl is the exception in that it holds more ash and doesn’t need to be emptied mid-session, but it still needs to be cleaned between sessions.

why does my cigar keep falling out of the ashtray rests?

Two causes: the rest is too narrow for the ring gauge of the cigar, or the rest angle is wrong. Wide ring gauge cigars (55 RG and above) need wider rests than budget ashtrays typically provide. The Stinky stirrup design solves this because the stirrup cradles the cigar from below rather than trying to hold it in a groove. If your cigar keeps rolling out of the rests on a groove-style ashtray, you may just need a larger or differently designed ashtray for the size you smoke.

what’s the difference between the stinky original and the stinky jr?

The Stinky Jr. is a 5-inch diameter mini version with 3 stirrups designed for one to two smokers. The Original is 8 inches with 4 stirrups. The Jr. works well as a personal solo ashtray, a travel ashtray, or a second ashtray for a different room. The bowl depth ratio is similar, so it retains the windproof design advantage in a smaller package. The Original is the better buy for most smokers because of the capacity, but the Jr. makes sense as a personal-size addition.

does the material of an ashtray affect the cigar?

No. Ashtray material has no effect on how a cigar smokes, burns, or tastes. The material only affects durability, appearance, ease of cleaning, and outdoor suitability. Choose based on where you use it and how you want it to look, not on any belief that one material is better for the cigar itself.

The Right Ashtray for You

For the most practical all-around buy, the Stinky Original is what the cigar community uses. The 3-inch deep bowl, 4 stirrups, and stainless construction make it the most functional option on this list. The Stinky Matte Black is the same design for anyone who prefers a darker finish.

For the best value under $25 for indoor and covered-patio use, the Craftsman’s Bench Neptune hits the right price and quality balance. For open-air outdoor use where you want something heavier that won’t shift in a breeze, the GUEVARA 8″ Round is the right call. For a proper cigar lounge setup without a table, the Stinky Floor Standing is the one piece that anchors the whole space. And for the car, the FESS Road Trip solves a problem no tabletop ashtray can.

Whatever you pick, empty it after every session and the ashtray will stay in good shape for years.

jay

Self proclaimed cigar expert. I've been smoking since 2010. I've practically lived at a cigar lounge from 10am to 10pm and trying every new cigar that came out for years.